Can Gunther repeat? Who wins the men's showdown?
Saturday, October 31, 2026 · 9:30 AM · Endicott, New York
Last year's front-runners return. One women's challenger has been running exceptionally quick 5Ks. Two finishers have traded places by seconds. And a pair of runners has crossed the line less than half a second apart in consecutive editions.
How this preview was built: We compared the publicly displayed 2026 names supplied from RunSignup's Find a Participant list with official Halloween 13K results from 2024 and 2025 and selected public race results from June–October 2026. This is a snapshot as of October 23, 2026, based on the latest participant list supplied to Confluence Running, not a confirmed final start list. Late entrants, transfers, withdrawals and race-day performances may change the picture. Full 13K competitors and relay entrants are treated separately.
123 Full 13K entries, and a broader men’s race
The October 23 registration snapshot supplied to Confluence Running contains 187 entries: 123 Full 13K runners, 60 relay participants and four volunteers. Relay participants are not relay teams, and team pairings cannot be confirmed from these individual entries.
Newby joins Cummings and Green
Jarrett Newby is verified in the Full 13K list. The YMCA’s 2026 5K results list 17:14, an older season benchmark that broadens the contender picture. Cummings’ returning 13K record remains useful, while Green adds a September 12 Camptown 10K finish.
What is actually recent?
Samantha Snead has an October 11 Steamtown result of 3:15:30 published final time. Nicholas Hekman has October 3 and 18 community XC finishes. August 5Ks are labeled as summer benchmarks.
The women’s rematch
Gunther led Smith by 26.82 seconds in Halloween 2025. Fisher, Snead and Fernald are current Full 13K entries with different race histories. Gunther remains a narrow Confluence pick, with no implied guarantee.
Relay crossover
Jordan Varano, Christopher Simser, Lauren Castellucci and Hope Szymaniak are current relay entries. Castellucci and Szymaniak won women’s STXC races this fall. Those results add relay interest without placing them in the individual 13K forecast.
Entry source: RunSignup public participant pages 1–4. Recent results: Camptown, Steamtown and STXC. Older benchmark: YMCA Corporate Challenge. Registration is not a start confirmation.
Date correction: Finish Lyme’s 20:14.32 women’s-winning 5K was run August 15. Its September race-report publication date is not the race date.
Meet the 2026 contenders
These are actual 2025 race photos, matched to Falcon Timing's results by visible bib number. Click a runner to explore their race history.
RETURNING MEN'S CONTENDER
Thomas Cummings
2025: Bib #74 · 48:57.99
Explore athlete profile
DEFENDING WOMEN'S CHAMPION
Emily Gunther
2025: Bib #101 · 52:23.32
Explore athlete profile
THE 27-SECOND REMATCH
Brieanne Smith
2025: Bib #431 · 52:50.14
Explore athlete profile
SPEED TO WATCH
Shelby Fisher
2025: Bib #86 · 54:41.75
Explore athlete profile
MEN'S CHALLENGER
Zackary Green
2025: Bib #97 · 51:37.40
Explore athlete profile
Photography: Confluence Running, October 26, 2025. View the 2025 Confluence photo gallery →. Bibs and times shown are from 2025, not assigned 2026 numbers.
How the field looks now
Jarrett Newby, Thomas Cummings and Zackary Green
Newby’s verified current entry changes the earlier Cummings-led preview. Cummings has the strongest returning 13K benchmark of this trio, while Newby has a faster older 2026 5K benchmark and Green a recent technical-trail finish. Those different races do not establish a precise finishing order.
Emily Gunther
The defending women’s champion has direct 13K evidence against Smith and Fisher. Her 20:14.32 Finish Lyme 5K is from August 15 and the Vestal XX 20K result is from June. These are older season benchmarks. Smith, Fisher, Snead and Fernald remain credible challengers.
These assessments combine the October 23 public entry snapshot with dated results. They are editorial judgments, not organizer seedings or predicted finish times.
The women's race could be the real thriller
Consider the three women who occupied consecutive positions in last year's top ten: Gunther (52:23.32), Brieanne Smith (52:50.14), and Shelby Fisher (54:41.75). All three names appear in the 2026 Full 13K entry snapshot. They have compelling but different recent evidence.
| Runner | 2025 Halloween 13K | Verified 2026 evidence | Pre-race take |
|---|---|---|---|
| Emily Gunther | 52:23.32 · first woman | 1:29:22.85 Vestal XX 20K · 20:14.32 Finish Lyme 5K | Early favorite: good evidence across distances |
| Shelby Fisher | 54:41.75 · third woman | 19:42 Kelly LaBare 5K, August 9 | Strongest speed-based challenger; excellent upset candidate |
| Brieanne Smith | 52:50.14 · second woman | 20:34 Kelly LaBare 5K, August 9 | Already proved she can stay close to Gunther over this 13K course |
| Samantha Snead | 57:08.05 · second woman in 2024 | 20:24 Kelly LaBare 5K; 3:15:30 published Steamtown Marathon final time in October | A credible contender with endurance evidence; October 11 marathon is endurance evidence, without a 13K time prediction |
| Carlyne Fernald | No directly verified 2025 result used | 20:32 Kelly LaBare 5K, August 9 | Could disrupt the expected top-four order |
Gunther beat Smith by only 26.82 seconds at Halloween last year. Fisher's August 5K was faster than the other listed women's contenders' August times cited here, but a 5K is not a 13K. Snead has a strong history of road racing from 5K to marathon; her October Steamtown result is evidence of endurance, not a prediction of her Halloween result. If all five start, the women's podium could easily be different from 2025. Read Samantha Snead's race-history profile →
Men’s field: Newby, Cummings and Green
Jarrett Newby now belongs in the men’s contender group. His public Full 13K entry is verified, and the YMCA’s 2026 Corporate Challenge results list a 17:14 5K. That is an older season benchmark, not a new September–October finish.
Thomas Cummings finished fourth at Halloween 2025 in 48:57.99, ahead of Zackary Green in fifth at 51:37.40. Cummings’ lead was 2:39.41. Green’s September 12 Camptown 10K of 48:46 adds current-window race evidence on a very different course.
John Salva, Eric DeHart, Alex Craver and Steve Esposito remain historical references and are not in the October 23 public Full 13K list. Jordan Varano and Christopher Simser are relay entries. Later registrations can change that picture. The men’s watchlist is broader than the earlier preview, and the evidence does not justify a precise podium order.
2025 Halloween 13K: Emily Gunther narrowly ahead of Brieanne Smith. Both appear in the 2026 entry snapshot.
Caitlin Zarnoch and Ryan McNamara crossed almost together in both the 2024 and 2025 13K.
Two genuine reversal stories, plus a double photo finish
Sara Gavette vs. Anthony Roe
2024: Gavette 1:31:39.64, Roe 1:31:39.94. Advantage Gavette by 0.30 seconds.
2025: Roe 1:32:17.01, Gavette 1:32:21.65. Advantage Roe by 4.64 seconds.
Both are listed for the 2026 individual 13K. A rivalry doesn't have to decide the overall victory to produce a finish worth watching.
Caitlin Zarnoch vs. Ryan McNamara
2024: Zarnoch 1:30:47.03, McNamara 1:30:47.18. Gap 0.15 seconds.
2025: Zarnoch 1:37:51.96, McNamara 1:37:52.31. Gap 0.35 seconds.
Two consecutive years, the same finishing order, and less than a second between them. They're both listed again.
Another comeback watch: Don Lavin (57:23.57), Lydia Dillon (57:36.30), and Katelyn Felter (58:17.04) finished 12th, 13th and 14th overall in 2025—just 53.47 seconds from first to third in that trio. All three are in the 2026 Full 13K snapshot.
Don't overlook the relay—but keep it separate
Two-person relay entrants run different legs, so comparing their relay times directly with individual 13K times would be misleading. Jordan Varano is an interesting example: winner of the entire 13K in 2014, second to Esposito in 2015, and listed for the relay in 2026. Christopher Simser is also in the 2026 relay list, not the individual 13K; his 2014–2015 historical head-to-head reversal with Jennifer Smith belongs in the race-history discussion, not an individual 2026 showdown.
From the 2025 gallery: past champions and rivals
These bib-indexed photographs are historical context. The 2025 winner and runner-up are not shown as 2026 Full 13K entrants in the snapshot used for this preview.
2025 champion's bib #1352025 bib #135 · View athlete history ↗
2025 runner-up's bib #1442025 bib #144 · View athlete history ↗
2025 head-to-head finisher's bib #1322025 bib #132 · View athlete history ↗
2025 third-place bib #1372025 bib #137 · View athlete history ↗
Photographs from the original 2025 race gallery; bibs cross-checked against the 2025 timing list.
What happens after Halloween?
The best pre-race predictions are ones we're willing to revisit. After October 31, Confluence can link the final race results here, identify which head-to-head matchups actually materialized, note which picks held up, and use the results to expand athlete race histories. The race card should connect readers to both Find a Participant now and the official results after the race.
Race results and source links
- Falcon Race Timing · 2025 Halloween 13K official overall results
- Falcon Race Timing · 2024 Halloween 13K official overall results
- Leone Timing · August 9, 2026 Kelly LaBare 5K results
- Falcon Race Timing · June 7, 2026 PawFest 5K results and July 4, 2026 4 on the 4th results
- Confluence · August 15, 2026 Finish Lyme 5K and June Vestal XX 20K
- Confluence · September 2026 Camptown Races and Owego Strawberry Festival 5K historical summary
- Confluence · Samantha Snead public results profile and October Steamtown marathon results comparison
- Public 2026 RunSignup Find a Participant list. May have changed since this preview was compiled.


















